Up until now, I actually did not know what the term "deaf-and-dumb" referred to. I'm glad that it's not considered acceptable to use that term, or the term "deaf-mute", anymore. Once again, it's not that Deaf people are unable to speak and it's not as if they haven't received speech training. The book states that "a congenitally, profoundly deaf child has, at most, 5% chance of developing intelligible speech" (209). And it makes sense. If you can't hear yourself talk, you can't hear yourself making mistakes and then correct them. You don't know how loud you are speaking or if the inflection is right. To me it seems like most of the time it would be a guessing game. So I agree that giving those Deaf people who don't speak a separate classification isn't fair. Besides, maybe they know how to speak but just don't want to. Deaf people don't give us the label "hearing and ASL impaired" or something like that. And hearing people have a much greater chance of being able to learn ASL than they do for learning to speak! Yet we're the ones assigning unfair labels. So I agree that assigning a separate label just isn't right.
There was one section of this chapter that I found to be pretty ironic, too. On the top of pg. 210, it states that deaf children whose first language is Sign language have a better chance of being able to learn speech than those children with strictly oralist education backgrounds. It kind of makes the whole "strictly oralism" attitude seem pretty absurd. They want their children to learn spoken English, yet they don't give them the great tool of an education in ASL to better the likelihood that they develop functional, intelligible speech. Pretty counter-intuitive if you ask me.
I can’t imagine how difficult it must be to be confident in speaking and your voice when you aren’t able to hear it. Your right, you wouldn’t know how loud you were talking or the inflection. I also agree that it isn’t fair place deaf people who don’t speak in a separate category or group. The labels seemed to be very harsh and inconsiderate.
ReplyDelete-Claire Graham-
I felt the same way when I read that deaf children had a better chance of speech if they learned signing first. Why would anyone put their kids through the struggle initially of learning an oralism if they are better off signing first. That shocked me.
ReplyDelete-Jordan Turner