This chapter discusses a student's question, "If you're deaf, how come you can talk?". In reality, it's not exactly an issue of can or cannot. Most Deaf people have a "perfectly normal voice appartus" (205). So it boils down to the extent and quality of voice training they receive and if they want to speak or not. The author of this chapter goes further to describe distinct groupings of people based on their modes of communication. There are 7 groups mentioned. The first group includes those born-deaf who have a strong Deaf-cultural affiliation. They usually prefer not to use their voices, but may do so anyway to communicate with hearing family members or other people with whom they feel comfortable. The second group includes those born-deaf or early-deafened who have good speech skills but are also ASL fluent. They may decide to discontinue the use of their voices altogether, or decide to use their voices only around hearing people. The third group includes people deafened in late childhood who attend deaf schools. They are ASL fluent and a part of the Deaf community. The fourth group includes progressively-deafened or late-deafened adults. These individuals are labeled "ex-hearing". The fifth group includes Deaf people from hearing families who don't become fluent in ASL because they have oral backgrounds. The sixth group includes those who are hard-of-hearing, from Deaf families, with about 60 dB of hearing loss (cutoff point for admission into deaf schools). Lastly, the seventh group includes those who don't learn to sign because they are strictly oral. They might have political bias against the Deaf community, as well. (206-207)
So basically there are a lot of different categories that people can fall into. I can see now why this isn't an easy question to answer. What I gather from it all is that being Deaf is more complex than they were born that way and they learned ASL because that's the best way for them to communicate. I can see why someone who is born-deaf into a Deaf family wouldn't feel the need to ever use their voice. If ASL is what you have been taught and its what you use to communicate with the people who are often the most important figures in your life, your family, then speech might not seem like such an important tool. This is especially true, I think, when one has a strong tie to the Deaf community. One's deafness would be not only accepted, but valued and appreciated. On the other hand, I can understand why someone is deafened later in their life, after already learning how to speak, would want to hold on to that ability. That person's connection would probably be with the hearing community, that's what they know. I'm not trying to say that they can't adapt and start making connections with the Deaf community, too, because I think that's important and a good way to cope with the stressful situation of suddenly losing an ability you have had some or most of your life. I can just understand why those people would be more willing to use their speaking ability. I have to say that last group, the strictly oral-deaf people, just sounds depressing! They can't communicate in ASL, meaning they can't really communicate with other Deaf people if they wanted to, and they have never heard their own voice before so learning to communicate solely through the use of speak has to be so hard! I don't know how they can feel a deep connection with any community. Maybe I'm wrong, but it just seems sad.
One last thing for this chapter! I like the paragraph at the end about hearing people not using their voices when in the company of Deaf friends, co-workers, or whoever it may be (207). I think that's a really polite and great thing to do. I don't necessarily think it's really rude if you do use your voice for a minute to communicate briefly with another hearing person, but it's nice if you don't. If the hearing person did have to speak to another person, I think it would also be polite if they then told their Deaf friends what information was exchanged when they were speaking.
No comments:
Post a Comment