Sunday, December 2, 2012

Chapter 34

I enjoyed reading this chapter mainly for the letter sent in by Roger Mindel that prompted it. He is a Hearing man who took up a new job where there was a Deaf woman working in the office with him. He wanted to learn how to communicate with her, even if just on a basic level, so he started taking classes in Sign Language and is now enrolled in a beginning ASL course at Gallaudet. According to Roger, learning about Deaf culture and language has been "a real eye-opener and extremely interesting" (201). What's more, he said he finds it hard to believe that he knew nothing about this language and culture even though he was surrounded by it (201). To me, this letter is incredibly valuable to the Hearing people reading this book. He is a great example of the response that Deaf people hope for when they meet a Hearing person. He took the initiative to learn his coworker's language, instead of expecting her to do all the work of figuring out how to communicate, and he even took interest in Deaf culture. He broke the stereotype of the ignorant Hearing person who knows nothing about the Deaf people, their language, or their culture. I guess I just think he can serve as a great example to other Hearing people. I am generally not of the opinion that all Hearing people are bad because they're ignorant of these things or that all Hearing people look down on Deaf people, but I do think more Hearing people should take on the challenge of learning ASL as he did. If you want to be able to communicate with someone and if you want them to respect you, as well, then you have to put forth just as much effort as the other person to make it happen.
In regard to the question addressed in the chapter, I think the question of whether or not one should expect a Deaf person to be able to verbalize is summed up nicely in the final sentences. "Speech should never be forced on, or demanded of, deaf people...It should be voluntary (203). I have heard Deaf people speak before and, yes, it doesn't sound the way a Hearing person's speech would sound. But obviously if you had never heard your own voice or the voices of others before, you would have no idea how you sounded to others or how to alter your voice to make it sound normal. I have a hard time wrapping my head around how anyone could learn to speak if they were Deaf. The fact that some are able to, even if their proficiency isn't very high, is incredible to me. I don't think it's fair to expect Deaf people to speak. In Mindel's case, I think it's very likely that, even though his coworker has said some understandable words, she's probably nervous to just start speaking. I know I would be! I agree with the advice the book gives: just ask her about it. Ask her how she feels about it and if she doesn't want to verbalize, don't try to force it. English is another language entirely from ASL, so the fact that she might be able to voice some words properly doesn't mean she should be expected to verbalize. Learning and speaking another language is a choice. It is admirable and useful, but not mandatory.

No comments:

Post a Comment