Monday, September 24, 2012

Chapters 8, 9, and 10


Chapter 8

Deaf students should absolutely have the opportunity to formally learn ASL. As a hearing child, my first language was English. I gathered and refined by English skills through my primary and secondary educations and I continue to refine them during my post-secondary years. Why should that be any different for the deaf? Yes, children learn ASL from their parents or from their friends, but did I not do the same with English? School fostered this growth and taught me rules and proper structure, too. Having courses in English throughout my education has been immensely beneficial for me, so it seems only fitting that deaf children should reap the same benefits from formal education in ASL. Of course, I could be wrong here. Maybe it doesn’t matter if you are taught formally or informally in ASL.

Chapter 9
I love plays on words. If you want me to laugh, throw a pun my way. In general, I just like the English language- reading, writing, speaking, etc. But when I look at ASL, I don’t find its humor lacking because they can’t fully appreciate jokes and puns that involve sounds. They simply have a different way of expressing humor that non-signing hearing people can’t fully appreciate. Because I love puns that rely on sounds so much, my first instinct was to feel bad for deaf people who can’t understand these subtleties of the English language. But, hey, they probably feel bad for me when I don’t get one of their jokes because I don’t understand the subtleties of ASL.
Ok, so I am going to just come out and say it. I kind of took offense to David Anthony’s comments. In just reading the first ten chapters of this book, I have learned way more about the deaf community than most hearing people probably know. But geez, lay off a little! “Their only concern is to un-Deaf us as much as possible.” Talk about a generalization. There are a lot of hearing people who really want to learn and be aware of ASL and Deaf culture. And there are a lot of accepting people who, even if they aren’t actively learning about Deaf culture, at least respect it.

Chapter 10

Well I guess I never really thought about there being Deaf accents. As usual, though, it makes sense. I would love to see a Deaf comedian imitate a hillbilly or a pompous Englishman. I wonder if I would get it right away. I suppose it’s similar to spoken language learning in that you can always tell when someone is a beginner or when they aren’t from your country. We can hear the difference between something who speaks with sophistication or someone who uses a lot of improper English. So in ASL, you can see the difference in someone’s signing. No doubt you could tell that I’m not a native signer!

Chapters 5, 6, and 7


Chapter 5
            I think it makes a lot of sense that ASL and BSL are different. If they developed independently of one another, differences are to be expected. It would be awesome to learn BSL but dang it’s daunting to think about! I already feel like I should be learning more than just Spanish as a spoken language and then I read this book and take this class and find out about how many sign languages there are, too. For now, just tackling ASL is keeping me busy enough! I think my favorite part of this chapter was the excerpt about Princess Diana. It seems like everything I read about her talks about all the great things she did. I always like to read about people who embrace different cultures and advocate for acceptance and equality. And I love reading about those who are bilingual! She put forth an effort to learn BSL and that is the best thing you can do to show respect for people: Learn their language, communicate on their terms. Even if you aren’t fluent and you are messing up left and right, people still appreciate the effort. Not to go off on a tangent, but I think that’s where Americans get a bad reputation. We expect other people to speak our language, which is immediately off-putting. That’s a small part of the reason why I want to learn other languages- to offset the negative view that other countries have of Americans. Mostly I just think knowing how to speak multiple languages is fun and challenging!

Chapter 6

I have to say, ASL syntax is a little tricky for me at times. I think it will just take some getting used to, though. I’m used to the English word order so I just need to spend some more time studying and practicing the ASL syntax. I think the Manually Coded English could be a useful tool for teaching English. I haven’t ever seen the system actually being used so I can’t really say that with any authority, but there has to be some way to teach English grammatical structures.

Chapter 7

I haven’t ever looked at a sign language dictionary. I would think it would be hard to learn very well that way. As a supplement, it might be nice, though. The most beneficial thing to do to learn ASL is to take a course. Although ASL doesn’t have a written form, I think the attempts to utilize a written form are very interesting. Of course, ASL is first and foremost a visual language, but having some kind of written form is a great way to grant permanence to something. I don’t know if that really portrayed what I am trying to say. It’s like in spoken language, there is oral tradition that has been passed down and is very important, but we still document history and events in books, giving it a sense of permanence. In ASL, the most important thing is visual/gestural language, but having some kind of written record helps in the preservation of deaf culture and history, too.