Chapter
8
Deaf
students should absolutely have the opportunity to formally learn ASL. As a
hearing child, my first language was English. I gathered and refined by English
skills through my primary and secondary educations and I continue to refine
them during my post-secondary years. Why should that be any different for the
deaf? Yes, children learn ASL from their parents or from their friends, but did
I not do the same with English? School fostered this growth and taught me rules
and proper structure, too. Having courses in English throughout my education
has been immensely beneficial for me, so it seems only fitting that deaf
children should reap the same benefits from formal education in ASL. Of course,
I could be wrong here. Maybe it doesn’t matter if you are taught formally or
informally in ASL.
Chapter
9
I
love plays on words. If you want me to laugh, throw a pun my way. In general, I
just like the English language- reading, writing, speaking, etc. But when I
look at ASL, I don’t find its humor lacking because they can’t fully appreciate
jokes and puns that involve sounds. They simply have a different way of
expressing humor that non-signing hearing people can’t fully appreciate. Because
I love puns that rely on sounds so much, my first instinct was to feel bad for
deaf people who can’t understand these subtleties of the English language. But,
hey, they probably feel bad for me when I don’t get one of their jokes because
I don’t understand the subtleties of ASL.
Ok,
so I am going to just come out and say it. I kind of took offense to David
Anthony’s comments. In just reading the first ten chapters of this book, I have
learned way more about the deaf community than most hearing people probably
know. But geez, lay off a little! “Their only concern is to un-Deaf us as much
as possible.” Talk about a generalization. There are a lot of hearing people
who really want to learn and be aware of ASL and Deaf culture. And there are a
lot of accepting people who, even if they aren’t actively learning about Deaf
culture, at least respect it.
Chapter
10
Well
I guess I never really thought about there being Deaf accents. As usual,
though, it makes sense. I would love to see a Deaf comedian imitate a hillbilly
or a pompous Englishman. I wonder if I would get it right away. I suppose it’s
similar to spoken language learning in that you can always tell when someone is
a beginner or when they aren’t from your country. We can hear the difference
between something who speaks with sophistication or someone who uses a lot of
improper English. So in ASL, you can see the difference in someone’s signing.
No doubt you could tell that I’m not a native signer!
I agree with you Natalie I never expected there to be puns in sign language but I think it would be fun learning some now that we are beginning to understand more about sign language. I also find Ch.2 interesting talking about “Gestuno” a universal sign language. I always had thought that sign language was sign language and never took the time to realize that there are so many variations, ASL, BSL, FSL, and so many more. I also really enjoyed learning about Princess Diana in Chapter 5. I respect her choice to do that and think that many others should attempt ASL in order to recognize the deaf community where we live. I think that you really took your time reading the first ten chapters of the book and I’m glad you find it just as interesting as I do!
ReplyDelete