Up until now, I actually did not know what the term "deaf-and-dumb" referred to. I'm glad that it's not considered acceptable to use that term, or the term "deaf-mute", anymore. Once again, it's not that Deaf people are unable to speak and it's not as if they haven't received speech training. The book states that "a congenitally, profoundly deaf child has, at most, 5% chance of developing intelligible speech" (209). And it makes sense. If you can't hear yourself talk, you can't hear yourself making mistakes and then correct them. You don't know how loud you are speaking or if the inflection is right. To me it seems like most of the time it would be a guessing game. So I agree that giving those Deaf people who don't speak a separate classification isn't fair. Besides, maybe they know how to speak but just don't want to. Deaf people don't give us the label "hearing and ASL impaired" or something like that. And hearing people have a much greater chance of being able to learn ASL than they do for learning to speak! Yet we're the ones assigning unfair labels. So I agree that assigning a separate label just isn't right.
There was one section of this chapter that I found to be pretty ironic, too. On the top of pg. 210, it states that deaf children whose first language is Sign language have a better chance of being able to learn speech than those children with strictly oralist education backgrounds. It kind of makes the whole "strictly oralism" attitude seem pretty absurd. They want their children to learn spoken English, yet they don't give them the great tool of an education in ASL to better the likelihood that they develop functional, intelligible speech. Pretty counter-intuitive if you ask me.
Thoughts on "For Hearing People Only"
Wednesday, December 5, 2012
Chapter 35
This chapter discusses a student's question, "If you're deaf, how come you can talk?". In reality, it's not exactly an issue of can or cannot. Most Deaf people have a "perfectly normal voice appartus" (205). So it boils down to the extent and quality of voice training they receive and if they want to speak or not. The author of this chapter goes further to describe distinct groupings of people based on their modes of communication. There are 7 groups mentioned. The first group includes those born-deaf who have a strong Deaf-cultural affiliation. They usually prefer not to use their voices, but may do so anyway to communicate with hearing family members or other people with whom they feel comfortable. The second group includes those born-deaf or early-deafened who have good speech skills but are also ASL fluent. They may decide to discontinue the use of their voices altogether, or decide to use their voices only around hearing people. The third group includes people deafened in late childhood who attend deaf schools. They are ASL fluent and a part of the Deaf community. The fourth group includes progressively-deafened or late-deafened adults. These individuals are labeled "ex-hearing". The fifth group includes Deaf people from hearing families who don't become fluent in ASL because they have oral backgrounds. The sixth group includes those who are hard-of-hearing, from Deaf families, with about 60 dB of hearing loss (cutoff point for admission into deaf schools). Lastly, the seventh group includes those who don't learn to sign because they are strictly oral. They might have political bias against the Deaf community, as well. (206-207)
So basically there are a lot of different categories that people can fall into. I can see now why this isn't an easy question to answer. What I gather from it all is that being Deaf is more complex than they were born that way and they learned ASL because that's the best way for them to communicate. I can see why someone who is born-deaf into a Deaf family wouldn't feel the need to ever use their voice. If ASL is what you have been taught and its what you use to communicate with the people who are often the most important figures in your life, your family, then speech might not seem like such an important tool. This is especially true, I think, when one has a strong tie to the Deaf community. One's deafness would be not only accepted, but valued and appreciated. On the other hand, I can understand why someone is deafened later in their life, after already learning how to speak, would want to hold on to that ability. That person's connection would probably be with the hearing community, that's what they know. I'm not trying to say that they can't adapt and start making connections with the Deaf community, too, because I think that's important and a good way to cope with the stressful situation of suddenly losing an ability you have had some or most of your life. I can just understand why those people would be more willing to use their speaking ability. I have to say that last group, the strictly oral-deaf people, just sounds depressing! They can't communicate in ASL, meaning they can't really communicate with other Deaf people if they wanted to, and they have never heard their own voice before so learning to communicate solely through the use of speak has to be so hard! I don't know how they can feel a deep connection with any community. Maybe I'm wrong, but it just seems sad.
One last thing for this chapter! I like the paragraph at the end about hearing people not using their voices when in the company of Deaf friends, co-workers, or whoever it may be (207). I think that's a really polite and great thing to do. I don't necessarily think it's really rude if you do use your voice for a minute to communicate briefly with another hearing person, but it's nice if you don't. If the hearing person did have to speak to another person, I think it would also be polite if they then told their Deaf friends what information was exchanged when they were speaking.
So basically there are a lot of different categories that people can fall into. I can see now why this isn't an easy question to answer. What I gather from it all is that being Deaf is more complex than they were born that way and they learned ASL because that's the best way for them to communicate. I can see why someone who is born-deaf into a Deaf family wouldn't feel the need to ever use their voice. If ASL is what you have been taught and its what you use to communicate with the people who are often the most important figures in your life, your family, then speech might not seem like such an important tool. This is especially true, I think, when one has a strong tie to the Deaf community. One's deafness would be not only accepted, but valued and appreciated. On the other hand, I can understand why someone is deafened later in their life, after already learning how to speak, would want to hold on to that ability. That person's connection would probably be with the hearing community, that's what they know. I'm not trying to say that they can't adapt and start making connections with the Deaf community, too, because I think that's important and a good way to cope with the stressful situation of suddenly losing an ability you have had some or most of your life. I can just understand why those people would be more willing to use their speaking ability. I have to say that last group, the strictly oral-deaf people, just sounds depressing! They can't communicate in ASL, meaning they can't really communicate with other Deaf people if they wanted to, and they have never heard their own voice before so learning to communicate solely through the use of speak has to be so hard! I don't know how they can feel a deep connection with any community. Maybe I'm wrong, but it just seems sad.
One last thing for this chapter! I like the paragraph at the end about hearing people not using their voices when in the company of Deaf friends, co-workers, or whoever it may be (207). I think that's a really polite and great thing to do. I don't necessarily think it's really rude if you do use your voice for a minute to communicate briefly with another hearing person, but it's nice if you don't. If the hearing person did have to speak to another person, I think it would also be polite if they then told their Deaf friends what information was exchanged when they were speaking.
Sunday, December 2, 2012
Chapter 34
I enjoyed reading this chapter mainly for the letter sent in by Roger Mindel that prompted it. He is a Hearing man who took up a new job where there was a Deaf woman working in the office with him. He wanted to learn how to communicate with her, even if just on a basic level, so he started taking classes in Sign Language and is now enrolled in a beginning ASL course at Gallaudet. According to Roger, learning about Deaf culture and language has been "a real eye-opener and extremely interesting" (201). What's more, he said he finds it hard to believe that he knew nothing about this language and culture even though he was surrounded by it (201). To me, this letter is incredibly valuable to the Hearing people reading this book. He is a great example of the response that Deaf people hope for when they meet a Hearing person. He took the initiative to learn his coworker's language, instead of expecting her to do all the work of figuring out how to communicate, and he even took interest in Deaf culture. He broke the stereotype of the ignorant Hearing person who knows nothing about the Deaf people, their language, or their culture. I guess I just think he can serve as a great example to other Hearing people. I am generally not of the opinion that all Hearing people are bad because they're ignorant of these things or that all Hearing people look down on Deaf people, but I do think more Hearing people should take on the challenge of learning ASL as he did. If you want to be able to communicate with someone and if you want them to respect you, as well, then you have to put forth just as much effort as the other person to make it happen.
In regard to the question addressed in the chapter, I think the question of whether or not one should expect a Deaf person to be able to verbalize is summed up nicely in the final sentences. "Speech should never be forced on, or demanded of, deaf people...It should be voluntary (203). I have heard Deaf people speak before and, yes, it doesn't sound the way a Hearing person's speech would sound. But obviously if you had never heard your own voice or the voices of others before, you would have no idea how you sounded to others or how to alter your voice to make it sound normal. I have a hard time wrapping my head around how anyone could learn to speak if they were Deaf. The fact that some are able to, even if their proficiency isn't very high, is incredible to me. I don't think it's fair to expect Deaf people to speak. In Mindel's case, I think it's very likely that, even though his coworker has said some understandable words, she's probably nervous to just start speaking. I know I would be! I agree with the advice the book gives: just ask her about it. Ask her how she feels about it and if she doesn't want to verbalize, don't try to force it. English is another language entirely from ASL, so the fact that she might be able to voice some words properly doesn't mean she should be expected to verbalize. Learning and speaking another language is a choice. It is admirable and useful, but not mandatory.
In regard to the question addressed in the chapter, I think the question of whether or not one should expect a Deaf person to be able to verbalize is summed up nicely in the final sentences. "Speech should never be forced on, or demanded of, deaf people...It should be voluntary (203). I have heard Deaf people speak before and, yes, it doesn't sound the way a Hearing person's speech would sound. But obviously if you had never heard your own voice or the voices of others before, you would have no idea how you sounded to others or how to alter your voice to make it sound normal. I have a hard time wrapping my head around how anyone could learn to speak if they were Deaf. The fact that some are able to, even if their proficiency isn't very high, is incredible to me. I don't think it's fair to expect Deaf people to speak. In Mindel's case, I think it's very likely that, even though his coworker has said some understandable words, she's probably nervous to just start speaking. I know I would be! I agree with the advice the book gives: just ask her about it. Ask her how she feels about it and if she doesn't want to verbalize, don't try to force it. English is another language entirely from ASL, so the fact that she might be able to voice some words properly doesn't mean she should be expected to verbalize. Learning and speaking another language is a choice. It is admirable and useful, but not mandatory.
Chapter 33
This chapter was especially good for me to read. It discussed why
Deaf people don't like speech pathologists. I am currently a Communication
Disorders major and, eventually, I hope to become a speech-language
pathologist. The authors of this chapter explained that the basic problem is in
the way speech pathologists view their Deaf clients, that is, contemptuously.
Sad as the situation is, the text indicates that speech pathologists don't view
ASL as the right way to communicate, only as a resource in social situations
(196-197). Unfortunately, I'm not incredibly educated on the subject, but it
seems that this opinion has a strong basis in the way Deaf students were
treated by teachers and speech pathologists earlier on in history. It's
terrible to think that anyone would use tactics like pinching or hitting a
child when they made a mistake, but according to the recollection of a Deaf man
in the book, being painfully pinched was a common occurrence (197). As
in abusive tactics formerly used in education, these practices have thankfully
been done away with. It seems that now speech pathologists are more respectful
toward Deaf people or at least use better approaches to speech therapy than
their predecessors.
From a
personal standpoint, this chapter has made me think more about my own future
career. I don't want to fall into the category of the speech pathologist who
does a poor or boring job of teaching speech to my Deaf clients. I really enjoy
learning ASL and I want to continue to learn. Even with the limited knowledge
that I have now, I would still be able to use some sign language during
sessions and hopefully that would make me a more effective speech pathologist.
If I end up working with Deaf people in the future, I want to be able to
provide the best services I can to my clients. I don't want to be the therapist
who looks at Deaf people signing and thinks that they should be using speech
instead and I certainly don't want to lie to my clients about their speech
skill levels as in the two recollections at the end of the chapter (198-199).
This chapter leads me to believe that whether or not you want to pursue
learning ASL, it is a good idea for any future speech pathologist to take an
ASL 1 class and learn about Deaf culture so we can continue to improve our
speech therapy approaches while respecting the importance of Deaf culture and
ASL as a useful and unique language.
Chapter 32
This chapter discussed the issue of whether or not all Deaf people can read lips. Apparently this is yet another misconception that a lot of Hearing people have about Deaf people. According to the text, there are many factors which make lipreading difficult. Sounds like "b" or "p" are nearly impossible to grasp by just watching mouth movements and everyone has different voice and articulation patterns (191-192). I know there have been times in my life when people have tried to mouth something to me and I have absolutely no idea what they're trying to say. It's usually pretty comical to watch because the other person always gets this crazy look on their face and starts mouthing the words very slowly, which, of course, does absolutely nothing to help me understand. While I understand that everyone cannot lipread, or more correctly speechread, I do know one Deaf woman who could read lips a little bit. I work a camp for adults with various disabilities for a week every summer and my first year I met Lisa. She was absolutely the funniest and nicest camper we had that year. Everyone loved her. At that point, I had never taken any ASL classes, so communication was difficult. She was a good sport, though, and sometimes she could figure out what I or one of the other counselors was trying to say by reading our lips. I thought it was cool that she had that ability, but I didn't fully appreciate it until I read this chapter!
I'm glad I learned the more accurate term for lipreading, too. It's better to call it speechreading because when someone is trying to read lips, they are looking at the entire face- expressions, gestures, posture, etc.- and they take into account associational cues, too (192). It isn't as simple as looking at someone's lips and knowing what they are trying to say. It's kind of like ASL in that you don't just look at the signer's hand, you look at their face. There is important meaning to be gathered from facial expression, even more so in ASL than in English. No matter what language you're trying to interpret or how you are trying to interpret it (by listening, reading signs, or speechreading), I'm learning just how crucial facial expressions really are.
I'm glad I learned the more accurate term for lipreading, too. It's better to call it speechreading because when someone is trying to read lips, they are looking at the entire face- expressions, gestures, posture, etc.- and they take into account associational cues, too (192). It isn't as simple as looking at someone's lips and knowing what they are trying to say. It's kind of like ASL in that you don't just look at the signer's hand, you look at their face. There is important meaning to be gathered from facial expression, even more so in ASL than in English. No matter what language you're trying to interpret or how you are trying to interpret it (by listening, reading signs, or speechreading), I'm learning just how crucial facial expressions really are.
Sunday, November 25, 2012
Chapter 31
Although, once again, the content of this chapter was a little bit dry, I did find the question that prompted the response to be very interesting. Roger Mindel wrote in requesting information about resources his wife, who works with children with learning problems, could use to help her better recognize children with hearing problems. My first thought was that she should already be aware of where to look if she works heavily with children with hearing problems. Regardless, numerous sources are listed to help her find more information. Some of these sources include the libraries of NTID/RIT, CSUN, and Gallaudet; the current TDI Blue Book; and various Deaf organizations and agencies in Maryland, where Roger Mindel lives, and Washington, D.C. (187-188). I think it's great that this man and his wife want to find more information about deafness and hearing problems so that she can better serve the children with whom she works. Since the past chapters have alluded to the sometimes sub-par education given to Deaf children, it is nice to see motivation from caregivers to seek out the best ways to help these children. To me, this is the kind of action that the Deaf community, and certainly the authors of this book, both need and want to improve the lives of people with total and partial deafness and the family members of Deaf people, as well.
Chapter 30
Not the most interesting chapter but it still provided useful information. It gave a lot of different options for finding resources for information about deafness. Some of these resources include the Gallaudet Encyclopedia of Deaf People and Deafness, the Laurent Clerc National Deaf Education Center, the National Association of the Deaf (NAD) and the NAD Law Center, the GLAD Bookstore, and The Encyclopedia of Deafness and Hearing Disoders (183-184). Another reliable option would be online databases, too. I use EBSCOhost through the WKU Libraries all the time to find peer-reviewed articles. I don't know if those databases would be good for finding just general information about deafness, but I'm sure they would provide interesting articles about research on deafness and Deaf culture. But if that doesn't work, I suppose grabbing a good old encyclopedia is a good option, too! At the end of this chapter, it is mentioned that many organizations like Gallaudet, NTID, CSUN, NAD, etc. publish magazines and other materials that can provide valuable, current information about deafness (184). I imagine magazine articles would be easy, interesting, and, above all, educational to read.
As far as the quiz at the end of this chapter, I got them all correct! I don't think the quizzes are meant to be particularly hard, but I find the material interesting for the most part so I think it sticks with me pretty well. I think these quizzes are good to give a little refresher on past chapters and make you reflect again on information you previously read. Sometimes I read things and I find them interesting, but then I forget about them the next day. These quizzes actually make me think back on the topics I have read about before and bring back to the front of my mind some valuable information. For example, number 5 asked about whether a native American language can qualify as a "foreign" language. It made me think back on how intrigued I was by that chapter and the debate on whether or not ASL should be considered a foreign language.
As far as the quiz at the end of this chapter, I got them all correct! I don't think the quizzes are meant to be particularly hard, but I find the material interesting for the most part so I think it sticks with me pretty well. I think these quizzes are good to give a little refresher on past chapters and make you reflect again on information you previously read. Sometimes I read things and I find them interesting, but then I forget about them the next day. These quizzes actually make me think back on the topics I have read about before and bring back to the front of my mind some valuable information. For example, number 5 asked about whether a native American language can qualify as a "foreign" language. It made me think back on how intrigued I was by that chapter and the debate on whether or not ASL should be considered a foreign language.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)