This chapter was especially good for me to read. It discussed why
Deaf people don't like speech pathologists. I am currently a Communication
Disorders major and, eventually, I hope to become a speech-language
pathologist. The authors of this chapter explained that the basic problem is in
the way speech pathologists view their Deaf clients, that is, contemptuously.
Sad as the situation is, the text indicates that speech pathologists don't view
ASL as the right way to communicate, only as a resource in social situations
(196-197). Unfortunately, I'm not incredibly educated on the subject, but it
seems that this opinion has a strong basis in the way Deaf students were
treated by teachers and speech pathologists earlier on in history. It's
terrible to think that anyone would use tactics like pinching or hitting a
child when they made a mistake, but according to the recollection of a Deaf man
in the book, being painfully pinched was a common occurrence (197). As
in abusive tactics formerly used in education, these practices have thankfully
been done away with. It seems that now speech pathologists are more respectful
toward Deaf people or at least use better approaches to speech therapy than
their predecessors.
From a
personal standpoint, this chapter has made me think more about my own future
career. I don't want to fall into the category of the speech pathologist who
does a poor or boring job of teaching speech to my Deaf clients. I really enjoy
learning ASL and I want to continue to learn. Even with the limited knowledge
that I have now, I would still be able to use some sign language during
sessions and hopefully that would make me a more effective speech pathologist.
If I end up working with Deaf people in the future, I want to be able to
provide the best services I can to my clients. I don't want to be the therapist
who looks at Deaf people signing and thinks that they should be using speech
instead and I certainly don't want to lie to my clients about their speech
skill levels as in the two recollections at the end of the chapter (198-199).
This chapter leads me to believe that whether or not you want to pursue
learning ASL, it is a good idea for any future speech pathologist to take an
ASL 1 class and learn about Deaf culture so we can continue to improve our
speech therapy approaches while respecting the importance of Deaf culture and
ASL as a useful and unique language.
No comments:
Post a Comment