Sunday, November 25, 2012
Chapter 28
This chapter addressed the topic of criticisms of deaf schools. If I had a Deaf child, I would do a lot of research into all schooling options. Based on the reading, I think the best option sounds like the charter school. According to the text, charter schools are "directly answerable to the parents for the progress and well-being of its students" and the school strongly supports an "ASL-based learning environment" (173). I would make sure that my child received training in ASL from a very young age so a school that relies heavily on ASL-based learning would be ideal. Also, I would want to be able to monitor the type of instruction that my child is receiving. Depending on the school, mainstreaming could be an option, too. The information in the text indicates that the experience of deaf student in regular, mainstream schools is mixed based on the programs, or lack thereof, designed for their education (172). If there was a particular school that had a great program for Deaf students, then I think mainstreaming would be a viable option. My concern would be for my child's interaction with the other students, namely the hearing students. If my child didn't feel accepted or able to relate to the other kids, I would probably explore other schooling options. I would want my child to be able to function well in the hearing community, but I'm not sure what kind of experience Deaf students have in regular public schools. If a school has a well-established and well-designed program, maybe they would work with the children on making friends within the hearing community. I wouldn't want them to lose out on the richness of Deaf culture, though. By sending my child to a charter school, he or she might have a better chance at making friendships with people he/she has something in common with. Basically, the type of schooling I would chose is a huge decision! It must be really hard for parents of Deaf children to figure out what to do! I know for sure that I would rule out any schools that highly emphasized oralism. I'm not too sure about deaf schools. Based on what I read in the text, that many deaf schools are closing and are criticized for providing sub-par education to their students (172), I think I would probably rule deaf schools out. However, I don't know much about deaf schools and it could be a huge shame that they are closing, so I would have to put a lot of research into that.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree with you totally! I feel too young and uneducated right now to say what I would do exactly. I would spend hours upon hours researching a choice to make and would only make it once I felt completely sure I knew the choice I was making was the right one!
ReplyDelete