Sunday, November 25, 2012

Chapter 26

Another very interesting chapter! I absolutely love to read. It is one of my favorite pastimes and I wouldn't want anyone to be denied the pleasure of a good book. For that reason, I both enjoyed reading this chapter and was saddened by what it had to say. I guess I never really thought about it before, but all the reasons that deaf people don't generally like to read make perfect sense. ASL doesn't have a traditional written form, so people whose primary language is ASL probably wouldn't feel as much of a need to learn to read. Also, language deprivation during early childhood and not enough emphasis on reading and writing in school make it even more difficult to learn to read (157). Personally, I think it can also be contributed to how daunting it is to try to learn a language with a completely different structure than your own. I kind of connect it to how English-speakers learn other spoken languages. It's incredibly difficult to learn Chinese because it uses a completely different symbol set than English and the words are totally unlike any words you would find in the English language. So a lot of people don't pursue learning Chinese, instead choosing something more similar to English, like Spanish or French. I know it isn't exactly the same situation, but I think the two bear some similarity.
In reading the misconceptions about Deaf people and reading, I determined that before reading this chapter, I probably would have assumed that deaf people were the silent bookworms. I can understand why people would think that deaf people felt a connection to reading because they can't hear and books don't require hearing to be understood and enjoyed. I don't think I would assume that a deaf person was an "illiterate dork", though. The fact is that neither of these ideas are correct. It all boils down to when and how a person was taught. The author of this chapter also adds that deaf people are more likely to get hooked on books if English was presented to them in a positive way (158).
I really liked reading the story by the Deaf man on pg. 161. I thought he made a very good point about the importance of having a Deaf teacher who understands how other Deaf people think and the struggles that they face. I think that, in general, people learn better from people they feel they can identify with. However, while I think his point about needing a teacher who understands the students is absolutely correct, I also think that even if the teacher isn't Deaf, but is a hearing person who is very well-educated about the Deaf community and the best ways to go about teaching them English, that hearing person would be very effective, too. Of course, the authors of this chapter  make this point, too, (162) but I wanted to reiterate it because their words mirror my sentiments on the matter.

1 comment:

  1. I didn’t think that either of the labels discussed in this chapter were accurate as well. The insight you provided stating that deaf people may find it challenging to read because there is no a written form of ASL, and the lack of schools emphasizing the importance of reading and writing is exactly what I thought of as well. You brought up a good point when you said that it may be more challenging because of the different sentence structures. I also agree that a hearing teacher can be very effective for teaching if they are well-educated involving matters in the deaf community.

    ReplyDelete