Saturday, October 27, 2012

Chapter 19

This chapter discussed the kind of confusing topic of Total Communication. Basically, my attempt to summarize the definition in the book is this: a teaching philosophy that combines different teaching methods, namely both speech and sign, to give deaf and hard-of-hearing individuals access to "a wide spectrum of useful forms of communication" (127). Simultaneous Communication is not actually TC, but a method of signing while talking (128). Lastly for the definitions, the Bilingual-Bicultural Approach uses ASL in the classroom to teach English (129). So  I suppose people have confused the three because they are all similar in that they take a different approach than strictly teaching oralism or strictly teaching ASL. In other words, there is some gray area. TC doesn't have an exact curriculum that states this is what we will teach in regard to signing and this is what we will teach in regard to oralism. There are varying degrees of reliance: one school or program might rely more heavily on oralism and supplement the lessons with signing or vice versa. I  think people probably confuse TC with Simultaneous Communication because Simultaneous Communication involves speaking and signing at the same time and TC involves speaking and signing, too. The difference lies in the fact that TC doesn't necessarily teach students to speak and sign at the same time. As far as the Bilingual-Bicultural Approach, the book says it's a new trend in deaf education (129) so maybe people just aren't as familiar with it yet. All in all, I think all three approaches are interesting. For a child with some residual hearing, a program that employs both speech and sign would probably be perfect. Maybe that way the person will be more able to find a place where they fit in in both the Hearing and the Deaf communities. While the definition of TC has been very badly misconstrued, I think at it's core it has potential to be a good system. It's one of those things that will probably always be difficult to pin point, though, because each case of individuals who are hard of hearing is different. Because of this, it would be next to impossible to  create a concrete definition or curriculum that applies to TC. I'm glad I know the difference between the three approaches now, since it seems like a topic that can create confusion.

2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Natalie,
    I also found this chapter a little confusing. I like how you said, "There are varying degrees of reliance". I think that TC, Sim-Com and Bilangual-Bicultural could all be effective systems. I agree with your comparison between TC and Sim-Com that's exactly what I thought as well. I think you are doing a fabulous job blogging!

    -Claire Graham-

    ReplyDelete